Peer Review Record

Manuscript ID: JOSTA-202610-2261

Article Title: Advancing Crop Improvement through Honeycomb Selection Design: Principles, Statistical Frameworks, Software Tools, and Applications: A Review

Double-anonymous review Accepted

Review Summary

ItemDetails
Submission Date12 October 2026
Editorial ScreeningCompleted
External Reviewers2
Review Rounds2
Revision TypeMinor Revision
Final DecisionAccepted
Acceptance Date09 November 2026

Editorial Assessment

The manuscript is a review of the honeycomb selection design (HSD), covering its theoretical background, geometric features, statistical approaches, software implementation, and applications in plant breeding. Reviewers found it well structured and of clear value to plant breeders, agricultural statisticians, and experimental designers, noting in particular its critical treatment of HSD limitations, including dependence among overlapping moving rings, the validity of the homeostasis index, and the difficulty of extrapolating performance from very wide spacing to commercial planting density. Reviewers considered the manuscript suitable for publication after minor corrections and suggested refinements to improve clarity and presentation. These included a clearer explanation of the competition concepts and of whether the design eliminates or only minimises competition; a schematic or worked example of the design; more detail on the parameter K; discussion of the statistical consequences of overlapping moving rings and of spatial mixed models; consistent definitions and notation for the selection indices; quantitative comparisons with conventional designs where available; a summary table of previous applications; clearer separation of evidence from honeycomb trials and from commercial-density validation; and fuller information on the rhoneycomb package. The authors satisfactorily addressed all comments, after which the manuscript was accepted for publication.

Review Timeline

Submission Received

12 October 2026

Manuscript submitted through the JOSTA submission portal.

Editorial Screening Completed

15 October 2026

Manuscript passed preliminary editorial checks.

Peer Review Initiated

18 October 2026

Two independent reviewers accepted the review assignment.

Reviewer Reports Received

31 October 2026

Reviewers recommended publication following minor revision.

Revised Manuscript Received

06 November 2026

Authors submitted a revised version addressing reviewer concerns.

Final Decision

09 November 2026

Accepted for publication.

Published Online

20 November 2026

Article published in Volume 2, Issue 4.

Key Issues Addressed During Revision

Reviewer concerns are summarised by category. Specific comments and author responses are confidential.

CategoryNature of ConcernStatus
Competition Concepts & Nil-Competition Allo-competition, auto-competition, iso-competition, and nil-competition explained more fully, including whether the honeycomb arrangement eliminates competition or primarily minimises it through wide plant spacing, and how it approximates nil-competition in practice ✓ Addressed
Design Illustration Schematic or photographs of the design added (plant spacing, central plants, neighbouring plants, moving rings, and control plants), with the HSD(E) formula and geometric representation checked and an example showing how a particular design works ✓ Addressed
Design Parameter K Effect of the parameter K on the allocation of entries and control plants elaborated, with a short comment on practical considerations in choosing K ✓ Addressed
Statistical Dependence & Spatial Modelling Clarified how overlapping moving rings create dependence among ring-adjusted observations and how this affects conventional t-tests and standard error estimation, with brief discussion of spatial correlation modelling, simulation, and spatial mixed models given the changing spatial dependence under local moving-ring references ✓ Addressed
Selection Indices & Notation Definitions and notation for PYE, HI, PPE, EPE, EYI, CRS, mPYE, and mPPE made consistent between text and tables, with the distinction between plant-level and entry-level indices kept clear, and the practical interpretation of the indices and how they differ from conventional selection criteria explained ✓ Addressed
Homeostasis Index Limitations Clarified that plant-to-plant variability within trials and variability across conditions are separate concepts ✓ Addressed
Comparison with Conventional Designs Statements on the advantages and effectiveness of HSD supported with quantitative comparisons with conventional field designs and modern spatial statistical approaches where such evidence is available ✓ Addressed
Extrapolation to Commercial Planting Emphasis added on validating selected genotypes under commercial planting conditions, including genotype-by-density and genotype-by-environment interactions, given the difficulty of extrapolating performance from ultra-wide spacing ✓ Addressed
Case Studies & Strength of Evidence Evidence from honeycomb trials distinguished from subsequent analyses under normal or commercial planting across the crop case studies, and a summary table of previous HSD applications added (crop, location, design characteristics, sample size, outcomes, and key findings) ✓ Addressed
Software Implementation Version of the rhoneycomb R package, a reproducible reference to its documentation, and an example of its use added to support practical adoption ✓ Addressed
Limitations & Multi-location Validation Limitations related to land, labour, statistical dependence, and the small number of independent validation studies complemented by emphasis on comparative multi-location studies across crop species and agroecological contexts ✓ Addressed
Formulas, Symbols & Table References Formulas checked for correct symbols, subscripts, and abbreviations, and table references verified ✓ Addressed

Peer Review Statement

Journal of Sustainable Technology in Agriculture (JOSTA) employs a double-anonymous peer review process. The identities of authors and reviewers remain mutually confidential throughout the review and publication process. Reviewer reports and correspondence are not published.

Voluntary reviewer disclosure. JOSTA respects reviewers' autonomy regarding attribution. A reviewer who wishes to be identified in the published article may notify the editorial office at any point before final acceptance. Upon written consent, the reviewer's name and affiliation will be acknowledged in the Publication & Reviewer Details section of the article. Reviewers who do not provide consent remain anonymous and are listed as Anonymous. This policy is strictly voluntary; no reviewer is under any obligation to disclose their identity.

This page provides a transparent summary of the editorial and peer-review process in accordance with JOSTA's open-science commitments. It does not constitute a full disclosure of reviewer comments or author responses.